Not The Best Deal?
This Grienke decision that’s gotten dragged out tells me one thing: neither offer is that good and his agent is shopping the offers to other clubs. Why else would they be waiting so long? Typically, all you need is two offers to create a competition but with the Dodgers claiming new financial restraint and the Giants never wanting to truly compete with anyone since the Zito fiasco, it’s possible that both offers are underwhelming for a free agent like ZG.
We’ll see. Maybe a decision comes today. And maybe he signs with a dark horse……….
I’m sure there are like 5 teams in the bidding.
RIP Scott Weiland. From Zumie on the last thread
This is from Velvet Revolver. A fairly kick-ass band.
“Let’s fast forward the clock five years and look at the San Francisco Giants lineup: leadoff hitter and now left fielder – Kelby Tomlinson, second – second basemen Joe Panik, third – third basemen Matt Duffy, cleanup and now playing first base – Buster Posey, fifth – Right Fielder Jarrett Parker, Sixth – shortstop Brandon Crawford, Seventh – catcher Andrew Susac, Eight – Center Fielder Mac Williamson, Ninth – Ace and just signed a six-year contract and entering his 30’s is Madison Bumgarner. Looks pretty similar to September of 2015 doesn’t it? Well that’s what the front office is looking at in the future. Bobby Evans and Brain Sabean have never shied away from off season moves and always looking for a big name to sign while not neglecting the farm system. That is what has made this dynasty such a powerful one. All players in this hypothetical lineup came up through the Giants farm system. Some came up fast, some slow. But the future looks bright for the Giants offense. How does their rotation look? With Madison Bumgarner, Zack Grienke (crossing fingers), Chris Heston, Clayton Blackburn, and Tyler Beede the rotation looks pretty solid with a healthy amount of young arms mixed with veteran talent.”
The aforementioned opening paragraph is from a very interesting column I just read:
http://network.yardbarker.com/mlb/article_external/what_will_the_san_francisco_giants_look_like_in_five_years/s1_7899_19990297?mb_edition=5248&linksrc=mb_favorites_head
Not that far-fetched, IMO.
Agree Chi. I still see Belt gone, so I see us getting a new 1st baseman or moving Posey to 1st (my preference). That bumps Susac up to the starting catcher . . . or, get a veteran via trade. Posey is approaching the age, where all outstanding catchers start breaking down and playing more at other positions. Here is a blurb from this article I just read: “Buster Posey hasn’t been getting better so much as he has been playing more games at first base. He has had 600 or more plate appearances in three out of the last four seasons. That is unheard of for a catcher, but the Giants have to get him into the lineup anyway they can. He is their best hitter by far. Posey highlights the problem with rankings. Yes, he is the best catcher in baseball, but that ranking doesn’t do him justice. He is head and shoulders above everyone at the position.” Consequently, I see him being moved if not next season, then the following season. Regardless, he will continue to PLAY A LOT AT FIRST BASE. BOOK IT!
Regarding the pitching staff, I don’t really like Heston, but I can see Blackburn and Beede in the rotation going forward – if not this year, then next season for sure. I also see them possibly being used as trade bait.
Like Willie, I like Williamson, but don’t know about Parker.
Agree on all points, Steve. Although, based on their production last year, Parker very well could end up with the team before Williamson.
Small sample sizes for both, and I think Williamson got most of the press, as he is supposed to be the guy with pop in his bat, but Parker blew him (and those of us who watched) away.
Again, very small sample sizes. I see both vying for a trip to the big club after both getting their “cup of coffee” last year.
Jarrett Parker:
21 G, 54 PA, 49 AB – .347, .407, .755, 1.163 – 6 HR, 2 2B.
Mac Williamson:
10 G, 34 PA, 32 AB – .219, .235, .281, .517 – 0 HR, 1 3B.
Williamson really did himself no favors. Dude looked completely lost at the plate, and I also think that Parker looked better in the OF.
They will both get good looks this year in ST, but I can see only one of them possibly cracking the roster right now.
http://www.baseballamerica.com/minors/san-francisco-giants-top-10-prospects/#.VmHV8p2Is9g.twitter
Short article but with links to stats for all 10. Chris Shaw? Well, let’s see.
I think Greinke could hold value for next few year if not longer. lesser lights like Samarz and Leake, doubtful.
Susac remains a large ?. I doubt he is near as bad as he looked last year, but to be everyday player he’ll have to improve at the plate, esp vs. RHP. He seemed to be hitting better before he got hurt, but really has had very few ABs, so it’s tough to see what kind of hitter he really is, yet. Potential, sure.
I have high hopes for Williamson as RH. Parker, idk, could be another bowker gang guy capable of big slumps where he doesn’t make contact. Didn’t look great in the OF either. I’d rather see J Heyward in Giants OF 2016 and taking over RF once Pence is done.
How many SF position players made it from 2010 to 2014 ring #3 beside Posey?
Pablo, although he played the bench for most of the 2010 PS.
RIP, Scott Weiland. Thanks for the share on the last thread, Zume…
snarkk and Pawlie (from last thread) – Mini-Flapalooza in Scottsdale would be badass. I will let you know when I have solid dates.
the panda made his decision around Thanksgiving last year, so Greinke’s a bit behind the curve, but not much. And Greinke’s choice is a close call. I can see why he’s taking time. He pays Calif. income tax with either SF or LA, so that factor doesn’t matter — as between those two. And he has no apparent ax to grind against the bums (as Pablo had against the Giants). LA’s trying to convince him that they’ll pull things together and keep Puig in a poke. SF’s trying to convince him that China Basin will be the best home he’ll ever have, and that the Giants are serious about adding an OF who can hit. Or something like that. In the meantime, the offers probably rise, too. I wonder how the Giants amazing manager/coaching staff stability and success weigh in. Bochy and Co. must look awfully good to a guy who saw DTT fail to control Puig and Eithier in the bums’ dugout.
I see no way that LA looks better than the Giants unless LA adds an extra year. I imagine both are offering similiar deals $/year-wise. I hope the Giants can land Grienke for 5 at about 160 or so.
And remember, Grienke is the one in the past who said that when multiple offers are on the table, he would take an offer worth one dollar more. If he was being truthful, I think that is outright fucking stupid. Come on, if your choices are between LA and SF, and LA is offering one buck more, that makes no damn sense. Our yard is a pitcher’s park, and anyone with a brain has to see the Giants are superior when you look at the manager and coaches.
Will be interesting to see how it all shakes out. Hopefully we know sooner rather than later.
It could come down to let’s say a larger bag of sunflower seeds for Grienke at that 1.00 figure then the dog hairs are willing to offer Chi…
Addendum to my 8:55am post – I also think Trevor Brown can handle the back up catching role, if not necessarily replace Posey in the starter’s role.
From what I have seen of Brown, he very well could be a servicable back-up, but I do not see him as the answer as a starting C.
he’s just a guy.
Belt is such a goner. The only questions are when and for who (whom?)…
I’m thinking Houston Loo. They desperately need a 1st baseman. Same deal with the Pirates.
Do either have spare quality controllable young pitching?
Mike Fiers, Lance McCullers and Collin McHugh . . . Belt might be sufficient to get Fiers or McCullers, whom I both like.
I wonder how much Greinke’s family situation plays into it. He’s married and has a child. They may decide to not make a big change at this time. Or maybe Greinke’s wife would be all-in on a new adventure in their lives.
I’m sure she’s all in on $180 million…
But what if the Dodgers offer $180 million and the Giants offer $185 million? It’s hard to think of $5 million being kind of insignificant, but at some point, it can be to the super-rich.
If it’s some broad making the decision, I’m sure she is thinking, “Los Angeles? San Francisco? WTF?” and then telling hubby, “Babykins, we’re getting the fuck out of this war zone and heading North.”
You can insulate yourself from the carnage pretty well with $180 mill.
Watch Soylent Green . . .
The longer this takes, the more I’m thinking Greinke will end up back with the Dodgers. The Giants should have already blown his mind with an offer, if they were super-seriously intent on getting him no matter what. If they’re trying to barely eek out a better offer than the Dodgers, then that doesn’t seem like it’s going to work, IMO.
Baggarly and Schulman (on twitter) just acknowledged that they got duped by the same fake Joel Sherman twitter account that led to my post last night (based on someone else’s repeat of a fake JS tweet). Somebody’s having a blast over the collective Greinke anxiety.
Don’t feel bad Xootie. I still think Dewey beat Truman…
My younger son at age 6 was sure that Barry Bonds just ate his vegetables.
lulz!
Barry Bonds officially Marlins new hitting coach…
Lackey to the Cubs – 2 / $36 mill.
Didn’t want him anyway.
Got that right Chuck!
Can’t stand Lackey!!!!!
And like I mentioned before..When Arnold pulled the mask off of the aliens face in Predator it was Lackey’s butt ugly face..Thank the universe I don’t have to see him in a Giants uni for 162 games plus playoffs of course this year!!
Tell us how you really feel!
And, in the ‘who gives a shit’ pile, the Arizona D-Bags have unveiled
.
.
.
.
new unis!
.
For a team in existence about 1/4 of my life, they’ve changed their uniforms about 15 times.
Man, that fried my hide when they won a championship in their FOURTH year of existence. At least they’ve suffered since.
Baggarly showed a pic of the 8 new az unis and asked “so what are they going wear in the 9th inning?”
🙂
I saw that San Diego is going retro with a brown jersey for Friday home games. The Padres achieved an amazing quality of dookie brown with those old brown unis.
And, of course, Brenly didn’t take it well when they jettisoned a lot of the team the next season. They ran Brenly out on a rail.
Yeah, for winning a WS in his all-too-brief coaching career, he hasn’t had a sniff at a coaching job since.
That video that Chuck posted of Velvet Revolver was also a good reminder of how good those ex-Guns and Roses musicians are. Guns and Roses was very talented, but so quickly imploded after gaining such rapid success.
Seeing as it took Axl 20 years to get Chinese Democracy out . . . Izzy Stradlin and Slash were the soul of that sound.
Velvet Revolver was very very good for their short lifespan.
My sources tell me that a GNR reunion is being negotiated and very possible within a year or so…
AZ now in on Grienke. Not a surprise at all, ZG camp is looking for a better offer than is being offered by the Giants or the Dodgers.
He’s probably holding out for 6/192. That ain’t for us.
I think we may land Zobrist and deal Belt 10 minutes later…
It’s not the worst thing if Greinke goes to the D-Backs. It would still be a set-back for the Dodgers. The Dodgers’ 3 division titles in a row was built on the Kershaw/Greinke one/two punch.
If anything that bomarera our chances. Those div titles got them bupkus.
Wtf? Bolsters. Phone+Bart = weirdness
Aaron Hernandez has been a choir boy in prison . . . uhh, except for the shank they just found hidden in his cell.
Grienke to a dark horse— D-backs. Pretty much exactly as today’s thread went.
They signed him?
Appears that way…
Wow! I am loving this . . . 2nd best thing to us not getting him (per Zum’s post which I agree with). Not worried at all.
And hell no on Heyward…he will be way way overpaid if the Angels are in on him…..
No idea where you guys are getting your info, but I am done bookmarking ESPN. Those MOFOs are always the last to know shit. This must be the 4th or 5th time in the last year, their info was from someone else.
6 year deal – no numbers yet…
Can’t wait until I read the fan comments in the LA Times (Zum you’re on the clock).
Dodgers with 4 left handers. Hilarious.
Another reason to get Cespedes…
Cueto (with elbow problems) is the only high end righty left. I wonder if the Bums make a run for him?
If Samarg goes to Dodgers I’m going to be pissed. I’d like to have him. I like him way more than Leake.
Giants need to move fast. Pickings are getting slim.
Jon Heyman @JonHeymanCBS 1m1 minute ago
greinke deal reported to be $206M by @Ken_Rosenthal. thats $34.3M/per. paul goldschmidt’s whole contract: $32M
$206 million…ridiculous. I was off by $56 million during my in-season prediction. Bus as I said the other day I would go $160 for 5 years tops…so f him.
And prescient lead Flav today…just read it after hearing of this crazy ass contract….hopefully Smardramjam does not think he is now worth $30 mill a year. Would think Dodgers go after Cueto super hard.
seemed clear to me after he fiddled around for a few days with both offers just sitting there. Everyone know ZG only cares about the $$$$. Giants/Dodgers didn’t bring the heat so they shopped the offers and got the D-backs to bite. They’re fucked, by the way, lol
If AZ signing Grienke means we end up with Leake, I’ll hate that Zack of shit forever.
hopefully Smarg who has way better shit and who I’ve always liked. Leake’s a GB pitcher, he never really made sense in SF long term……..
I’d like to point out one thing that’s been pissing me off for the last hour since I heard ZG signed with AZ: I sorted out what was happening this morning in my main thread. With zero inside info. Why can’t the national guys or the fucking beat guys figure this stuff out WITH access to the front offices? ALL OF THEM said this was down to the Giants and Dodgers and now guys like Pav (who I love) and others are saying they never saw the AZ thing happening.
I didn’t see the specific AZ thing happening either, but it was obvious that ZG didn’t have a blow-away offer on the table. How could they just not put 2 and 2 together and at least SUGGEST what an outsider like me saw clearly this morning?
Psychic Flav strikes again…
this was just a case of me thinking this through. I’ve been in some high end contract negotiations in my former career. The only reason this shit drags out is if the $ isn’t right (maybe the terms, but in this case it was obviously the dough). Clearly they were shopping it, got the D-backs to bite. Good for the Grienke’s….
Pav’s not the Lone Ranger . . . ESPN just posted this . . . KURKJIAN ON GREINKE: NO ONE SAW THIS COMING.
Sorry I put this comment on the wrong reply but hell no on Heyward…
Olney tweet . . .
Follow
Buster OlneyVerified account
@Buster_ESPN
BOS botched Lester talks& it cost them $217m to make up for that. LAD could have negotiated a Greinke deal in spring; big mistake, turns out
Most baseball FA negotiations don’t look like other deals I’ve seen. Greinke’s deal is different. His agent may have taken a simple rational approach — minimum 6 years and top dollar (oh, btw, Price’s price is the price to beat). Neither the Giants nor the bums wanted to commit to that length at that price. But other FA decisions involve personal idiosyncratic factors. Pablo’s decision last year was a perverse version of that approach. Cespedes’s original contract with Oakland depended on their promise to make him the starting CF immediately. Etc. Most huge commercial negotiations don’t have the personal preference factor.
I like it. Dodgers lose a Giant killer, D-Backs will be crippled by that signing for the next six years, and the Giants — as tempting as it would have been to bring someone in the caliber of Greinke to complement MadBum — won’t be saddled with such a ridiculous contract.
If Samardzija goes over $110 million, then adios. I would much rather have Iwakuma if alphabet gets greedy (which is likely after Price and Greinke hit the jackpot). Dan Szymborski’s ZiPS projection system has Iwakuma at $13.3 million over three seasons. Give him $15 million @ 3 years and see if that makes him move south to the Phone Park.
Forget what I said about Alphabet. Temporary insanity. MOFO isn’t worth it . . . http://www.yardbarker.com/mlb/articles/why_jeff_samardzijas_rumored_contract_is_a_big_problem_for_mlb/s1_12680_19995343?mb_edition=5251&linksrc=mb_favorites_head
I am pleased the Giants did not get Greinke. His AZ deal w/ no state income tax = a deal with SF at over $225M , which is ludicrous. Giants just need to get some type of arm now, and get a damn left-fielder…
Whatever happened to that guy Ludacris? Is it a guy? A group? A topical gel?
Do they still make Vitalis? Is anyone here old enough to remember that stuff?…
I’ve used ’em all, Snarkk.
Vitalis, Wildroot, Score, Groom ‘N Clean, etc.
Vitalis also made what I believe was the first men’s hair spray called Dry Control.
Maravich did commercials for it…
Alberto VO., Brylcreem, too.
I’m rather relieved. Hey, ZG gets to beat LA at least a few times. Cuhrazy.
I wish the Giants would just keep quiet about who they pursue. I don’t see the PR value in letting it be known they are after high cost pitchers, who they eventually do not sign. Keep things on the down low like Ariz, and surprise us…
like, sign Mike Pelfry?
Pelfrey [spelling]
Pelfrey signed with Tigers.
The Dodger fan blues, with F-bombs flying:
Well, fuck that.
by Catherine the Blue on Dec 4, 2015 | 5:06 PM up reply
easier to swallow than the Giants, but it is still fucking shit.
by RunRunItsHim on Dec 4, 2015 | 5:07 PM up reply
I can’t believe this
why the Dbacks?
by shawism on Dec 4, 2015 | 5:10 PM up reply
Greenbacks.
by joa_quin on Dec 4, 2015 | 5:10 PM up reply
I bet they got hosed
by hee came hee seop’d he choi’d on Dec 4, 2015 | 5:12 PM up reply
and magic was talking shit about jim buss lol
by ClayDavis on Dec 4, 2015 | 5:11 PM reply
The D’backs?
by berkowit28 on Dec 4, 2015 | 5:14 PM up reply
Greenbacks. Good one!
Tomorrow the NY Times is running its first front-page editorial, on the gun epidemic, since 1920.
I’m starting to think about escape routes and how to protect myself from shooters when I’m in public places. Seriously…
who can blame one? what a sad commentary on so-called civilized modern life
Former colleague of mine, now a Calif. judge (appointed by liberal J. Brown) once brought his Glock to my office to show me that it contained enough steel to set off a metal detector. Nice gun. I’m taking a dialectical approach, myself. Being a 64 year old in Oakland, I could use a Glock for self defense. But if I get one, I’ll also become a gun control activist. I’m serious.
So all the flapping in the breeze by the baseball beans didn’t exactly amount to a full hill but catching the flip on the Flap keeps one ahead of the curve.
In brew pub watching Pelicans v Cavs. Compared to Dubs, this is torture…
edit my 8:41 to Alberto VO5
Yes, VO is made by Seagram’s. Works better…
my father really liked VO when he was young
I still do, Xoot. I don’t think anyone under 50 drinks it. They used to call it a highball when you mixed it with ginger ale. When I was young, the old guys in the bar said I would graduate to scotch, but I never did. Just the smell of it makes me sick…
Dodger fans, still throwing F-bombs, and one “gosh damn”:
Scott Andes says
December 4, 2015:
I hate the front office. I really hate them. These are the brains? These guys are supposed to be the clever guys? They break up the best one-two starting pitching punch we’ve had since Koufax/Drsydale, and then they let him walk to a division rival. You know why? According to reports they were unwilling to give him a sixth year. They let the small market Dbacks outbid them? I’ll have more on this later when I am not seething angry. Let it sink in though guys. The Dodgers new front office refused to spend money they have plenty of to let their second best starting pitcher sign with a division rival.
You suck Friedman, you really really suck.
Blake Estes says:
December 4, 2015
The giants won it all 3 times in the last 6 years. We haven’t won the gosh damn thing since 88. This is LA. All or mother fucking nothing. Ya I’m mad. Can you tell?
At Price’s press conference today, he raved about how young and talented the Red Sox are. Young? Pablo, Hanley, Ortiz, and Pedroia? And I’m not sure their young guys are ALL that talented.
Was (KY’s own) Anthony Davis the best player on the court tonight in the Cleveland v. NOLA game?
Yeah. For the half or so I saw it, I thought at times LeBron looked bored or something. Curry and the Dubs are infinitely more watchable…
Unrelated baseball question – Google provides free cloud storage of 15 GB. Unfortunately, I have 42 GB stored there and they want me to upgrade my storage. Me? I want to copy all the files (mostly photos) onto my PC hard drive. Afterwards, I will delete all my photos, files, etc., on the Google Plus site. Is there a bullet proof process (web link) to do this, whereby the photos are still accessible by date? Thanks in advance . . .
Disregard. Resolved.
Didn’t fact check this, but someone on the radio said Dodgers open the season vs. AZ next year.
Also said no state tax in AZ.
Oh, who gives a shit…goodnight
Kershaw vs. Greinke will be a trippin’ thing to see.